At what point are we permitted to...?
Five questions, plus a sixth
1. At what point does it become irresponsible not to compare Israel’s slaughter of the Palestinian people with the genocide westerners know best: the Nazi Holocaust?
2. At what point does shielding Israel from the revulsion its actions naturally inspire not turn into complicity?
3. At what point should western publics be offered proper historical context to make sense of Israel's genocide: one that lets them understand how the Zionist movement was ideologically shaped by its exposure to ugly, century-old European ethnic nationalisms that culminated in Nazism, and how the Zionists chose to mirror those supremacist ideologies rather than reject them?
4. At what point are we allowed to say that Israel cannot continue to exist in its current form, as a racist, settler-colonial state masquerading as the “state of the Jews”, and that it must be remade, as apartheid South Africa once was?
5. And at what point are we permitted to prize Palestinian life over the "sensitivities" of Zionist supremacists?
6. Is the answer: Never?
[Many thanks to Matthew Alford for the audio reading of this article.]
All my posts are freely accessible, but my journalism is possible only because of the support of readers. If you liked this article or any of the others, please consider sharing it with friends and making a donation to support my work. You can do so by becoming a paid Substack subscriber, or donate via Paypal or my bank account, or alternatively set up a monthly direct debit mandate with GoCardless. A complete archive of my writings is available on my website. I’m on Twitter and Facebook.
Jonathan....a splendid set of questions and completely unanswerable by the powers that be and the enablers that allow these same powers of destruction to prevail. As an American Jew who chose at age 67 to pull up my roots and relocate to live and work as pioneer in the career and life design work desperately needed in China, I have solidified my understanding of the White Empire led by the USA with faithful vassals UK, Germany, Canada, Australia, France and Japan to name just a few, all clinging to the privilege and thievery and destruction endemic to Western "Civilization". The lust for power and domination precludes the potential embedded in a parthership rather than domination paradigm and will lead us over the edge and into the abyss of a new Dark Ages. How an ethnic group transmogrophises from victims of genocide into a lunatic genocide cult is a key to generating a genuine peace and love psychology.
We have long since passed every one of those points. Yesterday I was on a train and I came very close to standing up and addressing the other passengers about the genocide and our collective silence and complicity. But instead, out of some horribly misplaced fear and cowardice, I sat silently. Why? To save myself embarrassment? At what point, I have been asking myself for months, do I finally start speaking out loud, addressing my fellow citizens in super markets, at the bank, on trains about the genocide the U.S. (my country) is enabling? At what point do I find the courage to pollute the polite sanitized silence of public space with the terrible truths and quit allowing myself and others to maintain our comfortable complicit silence.