80 Comments
User's avatar
Jo Waller's avatar

Absolute rubbish. Of course ‘Trump’ (well his puppet masters in Washington and Wall Street) are in control of the Iran war. Trump’s soundbites are carefully constructed to make the public in the UK and Europe believe that the US is abandoning them and must up their own spending on NATO (ie US weapons), or to fool the Western public that the US is a puppet of Israel or that the US is doing the bombing of Iranians to liberate Iranian people.

The US is largely energy independent, they want energy volatility to destroy multipolarity and China’s economic rise, and for rising prices to make lots of money for big oil before the climate crisis becomes too devastating and obvious to continue to do so.

Jo Waller's avatar

The US doesn't want an off-ramp. They are merely using their proxy and attack dog Israel as plausible deniability and to sell the war to the Western public. Don't fall for it.

The ultimate aim of the US is to cut China off from energy, accelerate the climate crisis and re-emerge into hegemony after economic and environmental collapse everywhere else.

Don't lose sight of this.

Lynne's avatar

Netanyahus ultimate goal (apart from staying out of prison) is the creation of a Greater Israel that controls all oil in the Middle East, through a network of oil pipelines running through Israel to the coast

Richard Wilding's avatar

IT SEEMS IMPOSSIBLE to make any further comment on this accelerating barbaric shit-show.

Just another thankyou to JONATHAN COOK for again explaining an aspect of this global disaster with accessible clarity.

Richard Wilding's avatar

EXCEPT TO NOTE the deceitful shit spouted during the virtual conference of European foreign affairs ministers by the duplicitous UK Foreign Secretary YVETTE COOPER (LFI – effective Israeli asset)

Yaman Al-mouradi's avatar

Excellent article and analysis. Highly agree with most of the points made.

Generally speaking, this for the US is, in deed, turning out to be, at best, another Vietnam, or Russia's Afghanistan type fiasco. At worst, it could turn out to be one of Hitler's or Napoleon's Russia; In other words, a nightmare which, at best will result in a deep quagmire and long-lasting setbacks, or one that results in the beginning of the end of the US empire--a truly befitting and poetically just role for Trump, if I may say.

There is one thing missing, however, from this analysis. It is a very stupid option, but stupid seems to verily be the norm, in our current times. How could it not be? Just look who is at the helm; it's pretty much packed with a "who's who" of stupid people. I am, of course, referring to the nuclear option.

Internally, there's hardly anything stopping a war-crazed Netenyahu from persuing such a path. Externally, there is the US, but I don't see Trump taking any bold stands; when it comes to Israel, he seems to simply slink away and hide, like a toddler does when "the adults are speaking."

However, there are other external factors to reckon with. I believe, especially now that Iran has demonstrated its position and potential, Russia and/or China, may take further steps to deter such an option. Pakistan is, of course, locked-in in an ever-stalemate with India, and therefore would not play much of a role. While Russia is tied up in their war with the Ukraine--or NATO more like--which may diminish their role.

China, however, while typically insular, I believe would be rather foolish to allow Israel to degrade the situation further, much less do so through the use of a nuclear arsenal. Especially now, with the combination of having the US cutting its ties to Venezuela and much of South America, and strengthening ties with India, all while being ever-present in the Southeast China Sea. China, must recognize the attempt at strangulation, and bound to put its foot down--though they are not yet showing significant signs of such.

One thing I'm certain of, is that Netenyahu, and his warmongering cult of ultra-psychotic scumbags, would go that far, if nothing is there to deter him/them. Some may, foolishly in my opinion, think that Israel has been deploying the "madman theory," but the grim fact is that they are not; they are truly, a cult of actual madmen. If they are not brought to heel, they will inevitably lead this world into WWIII.

Yaman Al-mouradi's avatar

I agree with the general premise, but find it funny that the best off ramp is actually Israel. It's unfortunate that Trump won't likely do this. But the fact is, Netenyahu l started this mess; it was his stupid 40 year long cherished wet dream; he ought to fall on the sword he chose to foolishly raise, in my opinion. Trump could simply say that, and that the US wasn't well prepared for this; which it wasn't. Unfortunately, Trump can't think of this option, as it is the actual truth; something his subconscious regards as anathema. But truly Netenyahu ought to be the one to take the fall for this.

After that, maybe he can be finally tried for Genocide and put in jail, where he belongs. Trump can then take credit and get a real Nobel Peace prize. Wouldn't that be something?! But, I'm afraid it's too bold a move for Trump; but he doesn't have to go all the way. Just getting Netenyahu to take the fall for his stupid war would be enough for this mess to end.

Les Johnston's avatar

Well analysed and it highlights the sheer stupidity of the orange man. The surname "Trump" is now equated to idiot - forever.

The deceiving Israelis manipulated and fooled the orange man and now have him in their sights. The best option for the USA is to forcibly remove Trump and leave the war to the terrorist state without USA support. Be kind to Iran - it will do a handy service to USA.

Keith Harbaugh's avatar

Two addenda to Jonathan Cook's excellent article:

This morning, March 31, John Mearsheimer in a half hour interview with Judge Napolitano updated us with the unreleavedly gloomy way he sees the current geopolitical situation:

https://youtu.be/YKqf-3h0hM8

And if that isn't enough of a downer,

read how the Israel lobby has successfully persecuted Francesca Albanese for daring to criticize Israel:

https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/03/30/gaza-israel-un-criticize-us-sanction-00850477

Keith Harbaugh's avatar

And for a one-two punch on the geopolitical situation, hear John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt collaborate to discuss it (34 minutes):

https://youtu.be/NyvFSpZ7yYs

Richard Morchoe's avatar

"Trump needs to bring calm back to the markets as soon as possible to avoid a global depression and, with it, the collapse of his domestic support. He must find a way to reimpose stability."

Maybe he can salvage some support, but at this point, the mid-terms look lost. Not that the opposition looks like something to write home about.

Antonio Carty's avatar

I think the USA pursues global full spectrum dominance through sabotage of all other countrys, regions and relationships. The USA is a disenfranchised sham husk democracy, in truth it is an empire that is really directed by wealthy elites who set policy that either president follows and presents as their own in whatever their deliberately distracting personal style may be.

So USA is an unelected empire and that global dominance seeking empire elite has decided it wants to deliberately destroy the middle East's capability to produce and supply oil and gas to anyone else.

USA has its own oil so it reckons it can essentially ride out any storm, oil supply is essential to all nations so it wants to deny oil to its main competitor China whom it chooses to treat as an enemy. China is thriving through maintaining peaceful trade and development, it has a much larger population than USA and USA ruling elite wants to try knock China's prosperous power down by denying it oil supply from Venezuela, and by using Ukraine to excuse the CIA directing attacks on Russian oil and gas production and pipelines and shipping that supplies China and now the USA empire is destroying middle East supply to China. It is destroying it by simply poisoning the well with a war, to deliberately take it off the board and finally win it by blowing it up and denying it to others even if it further cripples Europe it's so called ally and anyone else.

The USA empire is a homicidal global Mafia and it can not forever force people to favour it and it's dollar currency by attacking and financially extorting us all. I hope Iran endures and that it's successful resistance turns the region into rejecting USA and the dollar because of the great injustice, harm and insecurity they have deliberately caused in the middle East and the world. This war is the war that begins to become too heavy to bear, it is the war were USA has clearly sabotaged allies and its chosen enemy's alike and it is their desperate reckless war of choice that broke the camel's back in the middle East and I hope their middle East camel's will never break their backs to carry them so self destructively again!

USA empire sabotages and divides the globe to try rule. It instigated Ukraine coup in 2014 to deliberately install an ethnically intolerant regime so that it would deliberately divide Ukraine down it's obvious ethnic fault line and provoke a civil war against over 10 million indigenous ethnic Russian communities living in what was the East of Ukraine, eventually murdering thousands of these people with USA NATO bombs and USA's Kiev regime ending Ukraine's neutrality in a hostile way against Russia succeeded in obliging Russia to enter Ukraine to try and protect the millions of ethnic Russian's rights to life and self determination and also to stop USA NATO installing hypersonic missile threat into Ukraine on Russia's border on 5 minutes launch time from Moscow an unacceptable usurping of Russia's security, like USA installing a gun to Moscow's head and USA knew Russia would have to react between a rock and a hard place and Russia did act to face and tried to quickly dismantle the threat but it was a USA NATO trap that Russia was forced to knowingly try to dismantle and USA NATO refused to let peaceful settlement between Russia and Ukraine break out, USA and it's NATO has deliberately maintained a war to sabotage Russia and the region and also by forcing Russia to go to war to stop the threat and injustice USA's pursuit of global full spectrum dominance also succeeded in dividing Europe and Russians former mutually prosperous and peaceful trade and resource relationship that was vital to supplying Europe with cheap gas, because USA psychotic elite's pursuit of global dominance sees all other nations and regional relationships around the world that create peaceful prosperity as a threat to USA empire's ability to be dominant, even it's so called allies, so USA deliberately sabotaged Europe through creating the war in Ukraine and dividing Europe and Russia because Europe's prosperity and peace with Russia was seen as a competitor threat to USA empire power and we see now that Europe has indeed been weekend by the Ukraine war because it cut off cheap Russian oil and gas supply and drained resources and now Europe buys the gas it needs at 4x times the price from USA instead!

Europe's most militarized countrys are spending more and more on weapons to continue this self destructive war against Russia that only suits European and USA elites that wish to maintain a corporate monopoly seeking terrorist Mafia empire that rules by impoverishing and sabotaging all regions of Earth including European and USA ordinary publics, distracting and dividing us all into animosity and confusion while they harvest wealth by dominating resources and ruling through manipulative dollar dominance tyranny.

We all must Refuse the dollar, untangle from it and refuse USA global militarism and warmongering and USA's disenfranchised people will hopefully begin to refuse both their corporate owned political party's playing good cop bad cop by polarizing public through trigger issues that deliberately distract the public so they vote for one party against the other when both are funded by and only really act to serve the wealthy and their global sabotage empire racket.

I hope Iran and Palestine and all nations will endure to secure their own rightful self determination and USA public will reject both corrupt party's and demand a real representative choice in their democracy and that this will be a turning point to a fairer more representative multipolar world where all regions and peoples of world can work and have a representation of their needs security and interests not dominated by any one power but a balance of power that creates mutually agreed fair laws that all cooperate with and can rely on that allows stability and confidence everywhere, that their is peace, justice and sustainable egalitarian prosperity for our love and health to grow and live together in this world we must share!

Cheers, Antonio from Ireland

Richard Wilding's avatar

That about covers it.

AJ Birchall's avatar

Where does Israel get its oil from? Will they run out of it?

Synthetic Civilization's avatar

The hardest part of modern power is no longer striking. It is restoring order afterward.

And some actors increasingly prefer chaos to settlement because chaos can be strategically productive.

Davina's avatar

If Drumpf would stop fire a ery few minutes and read what the world sees satanyahu's scheming ways because he sees Drumpf as an incompetent fool, to be used and laughed at behind his back, because he, Drumpf, the dullard, is totally beneath the israeli.

Rafi Simonton's avatar

WWI was a desperate attempt to preserve empire and which we're still fighting. After WWI, the British and French divided the Ottoman empire to suit their own fantasies of empire, locals never consulted. Including the Arabs who had fought on the Allied side. The Anglophoney fantasy of dominating the world economically and politically, justified as defending culture, freedom, and democracy, kept alive after WWII (through lots more death) by the U.S.

More likely to come as the world heats up. The aggression of Zionist Israel, backed by western Europe and colonist descendants, is a rehearsal for how to handle desperate climate refugees. In the U.S. it's with the so-called illegals. Subhumans, if not killed outright at the border, are to be herded into concentration camps. Citizens are to accept this as necessary for national survival. Anyone who objects on moral or philosophical grounds will be denounced, silenced, or sent to join the detainees.

The Doomsday clock on the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists is at 85 seconds to midnight, closest ever. We must stop the inhumanity now! Or hundred of millions will soon die in the climate chaos or if the Zionists feel entitled by "never again" to take the world with them by launching the nukes.

enactive_agent's avatar

Eschatology and empire seem inextricably linked

Michael Sells's avatar

You describe the situation well. As for Jake Sullivan: After helping preside over the Usraeli demolition of Gaza, did he think that had anything to do with defeating Hamas? No, he knew it was just a pretext for making Gaza unlivable and he was happy to oblige.

Duane McPherson's avatar

Jake the Snake, a Zionist to the core.

Frank Sterle Jr.'s avatar

It's very unlikely the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel was truly unexpected by Israeli intelligence, albeit it may have been deadlier than the hypothetical Israeli insiders had anticipated. Regardless of the increasingly self-compromised mostly-corporatized Western mainstream news-media (unlike genuinely independent news outlets) basically deeming it non-newsworthy, it's no real secret that Israeli officials had been warned in advance by at least one credible source.

Those Israeli lives lost may be considered by the increasingly immorally opportunistic prime minister, and ilk, as a good investment or return — i.e. the future mass cleansing of Palestinians from their land, followed by its annexation along with its coveted natural resources. The 10/7/23 assault conveniently enabled the Netanyahu government/IDF to justify or excuse extreme emergency war measures, then force through his/their ‘democratic reforms’ and do who-knows-what-more to Palestine.

With similarly great violence-filled hatred and mass-vengeance rage as that felt and implemented by Israelis following the 10/7 Hamas attack, the simplistic mentality and war-monger justification [“Israel has the right to defend itself”] was effectively utilized by the Cheney-Bush U.S. administration immediately after 9/11 — especially for the plainly unjustifiable American/British foreign invasion of oil-laden Iraq. [I refer to it as the Cheney-Bush administration, since it was mostly run by Cheney, with George W. essentially symbolically president.]

And, of course, if Iran militarily surrenders to Western forces thus big corporate interests, soon-enough afterwards it will also be compelled to surrender access to much of its vast fossil fuel reserves to American and British ‘energy’ companies. Those corporations — and Israel’s government/interests as well — know there's still much to be effectively appropriated.

Rafi Simonton's avatar

Add this--which few D party loyalists seem aware of--Biden's Dept. of State was run by neocons trained by Cheney.

Patrick Taylor's avatar

I have read somewhere that the festival attacked at the outset was originally scheduled to happen in Northern Israel but at short notice was moved close to Gaza. I would dearly love to have that information confirmed or clarified.

The notion that Mossad and the Army Command had no knowledge of an attack seems extremely unlikely. It is known from the female Israeli soldiers in the watchtowers they had been reporting for weeks of activity practicing breaching the fence line.

The festival goers were the sacrificial lambs to justify an all out assault on Gaza.

Patrick Taylor's avatar

Further to my post above a search on Reddit leads to a very lengthy thread discussing the matter. Essentially it apparently was due to happen at another kibbutz not very much further away according to one source. The army approved the move which is about 3.5km from the fence.

The change in venue not being a significant distance from the original venue meant minimal disruption to the acts and audience.

Egypt had told Israel of an attack 3 days before according to proper sources

The actual site was already setup from a concert the previous night. It is likely that the music could be heard in Gaza!

In any event the use a Apache gunship to shoot up moving targets might have lead to many of the 260 deaths. However reading the Reddit thread is interesting- l would link it to under No Stupid Questions but cannot currently locate the thread.

Richard Wilding's avatar

It's likely most of the casualties on Oct 7th were caused by missiles from IDF ground attack helicopters and shellfire and heavy machinegun fire from IDF tanks and APCs.

Haaretz newspaper (now denounced by the Netanyahu gangster government) reported that IDF command on the ground that day invoked the 'Hannibal Doctrine' specifically (by name).