109 Comments

Jonathan.anexcellent article as usual.i tried raising these points here in a debate but as you would expect they thought I was anti Semitic and a jew hater.the usual rubbish.israelis simply refuse to face the fact that its our oppression that created Hamas.

Expand full comment

Did it meantion Netenyue and his facilitation of their existence? As a means of splitting the Palistinians from the West bank. (Fail) While Israel controlled the West banks government using proxy political shills ? Yeah I thought not.

Expand full comment

👏👏👏

Expand full comment

Yes, indeed. I don't pay a tv licence because I won't pay to be told lies. Many Scottish people have done the same. There are more reliable sources of news and information.

Expand full comment

The greatest show on Earth? Not!

https://liborsoural.substack.com/p/never-enough

Expand full comment

You say more than 30,000 Palestinians have been killed since Oct 7. Do you have a precise estimate and is this updated info?

Expand full comment

Wait. Isn’t Hamas A jihadist organization? Given that their stated purpose is to kill all nonbelievers you are also on that list. As are in rough order, Jews, homosexuals, Christians, and anyone who isn’t a jihadist. I don’t see them negotiating for peace as that is contrary to their objective. I too want peace and security for all parties.

By the way the League of Nations gave the territory they were ceded by the failed Ottoman Empire after WWI to the Arabs (Jordan) and the Jews (Israel). There is no Palestine country, no specific Palestine race or ethnicity. They are all Arabs.

Expand full comment

Thank you once again. I have just been to a vigil for dead Palestinian journalists outside the BBC at Salford Quays. This week I have been monitoring the appalling Radio 4 news output, almost complete silence about the ICJ on Monday, but so much time for the rise in antisemitism based on statistics of Community Security Trust. And lots of time for Navalny but nothing for the Palestinian resistance. Not a word for the thousands of dead children but 5 minutes for the only possible atrocity: Hamas’ taking of hostages. The evil empire is completely naked. Thanks for pointing at it!

Expand full comment

I wonder why Jonathan didn't mention it?

Expand full comment

This is what 99.5% of the reporting on this situation looks like here in the US. It is nearly impossible for Americans who were not already concerned and educated about the apartheid state that existed in Palestine and was operated by Israel to get an accurate description of the situation on the ground. When today's veto on a ceasefire came down from the US it was not even covered on any of the major newspaper or news channels. The Guardian's US site did cover it but I have to point out that the majority of Americans are not getting their news from The Guardian. Too many "liberal" news agencies are doing their best to ignore the war crimes being carried out because of our government's blatant denial about the behavior of the Israeli administration and military. They are instead being even more vociferous in their canonization of Biden as all that is standing between us and Christofacism. Too bad Biden himself seems determined to act in ways that they would find unacceptable in any other candidate or administration prior to Trump. But they are choosing to forget that it was precisely due to the media treating Trump like a serious candidate and both-sides garbage equivocation that got Trump 24/7 coverage. They made that mess and now they are either sticking with it (Fox News), repeating the same mistakes they made last time and ignoring the very real interference AIPAC has accomplished across both parties and covering a presidential election that doesn't happen until November (CNN, most newspapers) or they are hammering on Progressives in advance for any hesitancy in supporting Biden as giving Donald Trump and his nefarious buffoonery another presidency, one that will be the end of American democracy. Never mind the war crimes, never mind destroying what small amount of global goodwill our government hadn't already squandered by using our security council veto power to force the opposite of democratic decision making onto the UN with our one veto overruling 13 votes FOR a ceasefire. It's almost like they realized the optics are completely fucked up so they sat on the story. I fucking hate everything about my country's politics. How about Biden acting like he gives a fuck about what voters want? Why don't they cover the fact that he's determined to hand Trump the election and not frame the only sane citizens as traitors and antisemites?

Expand full comment

It goes much deeper than what you see and think - the optics are nothing more than window dressing

Expand full comment

Excellent article....it's sad and shocking that so many believe the rubbish that the BBC and indeed all the mass media spout out on a daily basis. Thank goodness for you Jonathan...and all those who stand for truth.

Expand full comment

Great article again JC, but I was surprised you didn't mention one of the crucial necessities for the tunnels, namely smuggling food, medicine & fuel. A necessity for prisoners whose captors control EVERYTHING even calories consumed.

Expand full comment

Bravo Jonathan!!

You’ve given the venerated BBC a lesson on the dos and don’ts of journalism .

They should hire you as a consultant.

Expand full comment

more media lies

The story of the “rescue of the two Israeli captives” in Gaza is totally bogus

https://www.chroniquepalestine.com/histoire-sauvetage-deux-captifs-israeliens-dans-gaza-est-totalement-bidon/

Expand full comment